Northern Edition
Select Edition
Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Damning image of Lion emerges after series win with major backlash online

Will Skelton of the Wallabies and Andrew Porter of the British and Irish Lions clash as James Ryan of the British and Irish Lions receives medical treatment on the ground during the third test of the series between Australia Wallabies and British & Irish Lions at Accor Stadium on August 02, 2025 in Sydney, Australia. (Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

The British & Irish Lions may have come away victorious in their series against Australia, but their humbling third Test loss in Sydney left a sour taste in fans’ mouths, with various players’ performances called into question.

ADVERTISEMENT

One of those was loosehead prop Andrew Porter, whose scrummaging technique was called into question yet again by fans online. The angle in which Ireland and Leinster’s 125kg prop drives in the scrum has long been queried and called out by fans, but those calls reached fever pitch after his third Test performance against the Wallabies.

The 29-year-old was in no way on the right side of referee Nika Amashukeli’s whistle in the loss, but fans online are still dismayed by what he was able to get away with.

Just hours after the match, ‘Front Row Grunt’ shared an aerial image of Porter’s scrummaging, where he was effectively driving at a 90° angle, writing: “Porter up to his normal tricks again yesterday…. And the most astonishing thing is? It was the Aussies who got penalised in this scrum!”

This post had dozens of fans commenting in agreement, with ‘Scrummaging Flyhalf’, who also called out Porter’s scrummaging in the second Test online, writing “Not even Shane Warne got that much turn in Australia!”

Former referee Nigel Owens did offer a defence for the Irishman, writing: “Although I am not disputing either way with you on this image, you can only make an accurate call if you see the whole sequence in motion, not just a still image.”

Many others shared similar posts online, including ‘Scoop Rugby’, who wrote: “I’m sorry but Andrew Porter on those aerial views is a f**ckn criminal for the way he binds down to scrum. WOW. And they are all in front of the referee!!!”

ADVERTISEMENT

One fan wrote, “How Porter is allowed to scrummage at that angle is beyond me. Should be a penalty almost every scrum,” while another wrote “, Andrew Porter would never win a scrum if he was forced to scrum straight. Nika allowing him to scrum skew just to get the ball out.” 

Porter was swiftly taken off just minutes into the second half of the final Test and replaced with Ellis Genge, who proceeded to win his own scrum penalty.

Related


Enter our competition and you could be the lucky winner of a signed British and Irish Lions 2025 shirt! Enter here now

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

32 Comments
P
PL 4 days ago

I was a ref referee coach and assesor for 17 seasons most at level 2

Stills or videodont matter straight square and steady is the requirement - a la hamlet Porter honours it in the breach


The tezzano hit was worse you can’t impact or hit above the sternum

Best you can say that ref reds to attend an optometrist

The mouth are reading kills the Lions bull dust of staging

That’s red e ery day of the week


There will be no game cause insurance will become unobtainable due to refs not applying laws to stop the deaths some seasons ago of head injury laws


Powys v Evans leave refused to House of Lords held the ref responsible for 2 million quadriplegic case plus the Home Unions bailed the ref and the welsh r u out


No insurance coy will touch rugby insurance if refs don’t apply the laws properly

C
CrossStitcher69 5 days ago

If Porter has been getting away with anything that must be down to WR employing terrible refs. The only ref to regularly ping him at test level was the notoriously biased Wayne Barnes. Top ex-pros like Professor Scrum himself, David Flatman has consistently lauded Porter’s strong scrummaging performances.

P
PR 6 days ago

I spoken about this on other sites YouTube especially and to me it's disgusting as someone has already said he should be penalised at every scrum you think how much this has helped this Irish side in the past, scrum on the half way line porter bores in at that crazy angle clown refs give a penalty to Ireland they kick to the corner and they are 5 yards out line out rolling maul try conversion 7 points rugby is a joke I've been watching for over 50 years how could you explain that to anyone when they say scrumage straight and I don't want to hear Nigel owens defend it either this lions team were lucky to beat Australia some of the decisions have been ridiculous look at a 4 match ban for sheehan never looked at or seen by 4 officials who were calling some crazy decisions especially the 4th ref in the box so basically that would have been a red card get real rugby sort out the refs this is a dying sport and no wonder

Z
Zino 6 days ago

The referee has a duty of care to protect the players from serious injury. Soon as a prop drives at an angle he should blow up instantly in the interest of player safety. It seems that this foul play is poorly policed by match officials and world rugby who allegedly takes players safety very seriously needs to issue clear guidelines for players and officials

C
CT 6 days ago

I've never been impressed by him he's really average in every way

N
Nik 6 days ago

It was embarrassing to see Porter selected ahead of Genge. One of them was the best loosehead in the series, the other was Irish and therefore 3 steps higher on the selection ladder.

a
aO 5 days ago

A Brit writing this no doubt. That jealousy is what all of this is about. Itoge had a terrible series yet you don't mention him or Freeman or Kinghorn

d
dk 6 days ago

He’s an awful player. Weak, can’t carry and too short. The fact refs don’t call him shows the influence the northern hemisphere unions have on the IRB and their referee selection. And there is no way the tall dwarf is 120kgs. All 5 foot of him.

T
Tom 6 days ago

To be fair, he's not weak, he has a massive squat.

M
MM 6 days ago

That image says it all. Porter isn't scruming straight.

C
CH 6 days ago

Of course Porter scrummed in and he kept dropping his elbow causing scrum to collapse and even won penalties. For this action in the second test.


Ppersonally the referees and assistant refs need to be tackled on this issue.


Had they dealt with it early in the game, he might have changed or been yellow carded for repeat offences.

B
BH 7 days ago

Porter is a sore loser that can’t handle getting penalised for his illegal and crooked scrummaging.


He was driving on a 45° angle multiple times in Game 3. One of them was so bad you could drive a bus between Sheehan and himself.

J
JWH 5 days ago

45 is generous. I would say right angle most of the time

C
CD older/wiser 7 days ago

Having been a light weight hooker myself years ago, when rugby hookers had to actually hook the ball. I believe the biggest problem is the majority of rugby officials, if not all of them, have only ever played in the back line themselves and really no idea what happens in the scrums .

J
JWH 5 days ago

Well to be fair these guys are professional and get trained in understanding the key parts of what leads to a scrum pen i.e. gait showing inwards is driving in, elbow or knee down first is collapsing, head popping first is standing up, and so on.

F
Flankly 7 days ago

It is Porter’s party trick. He does a version of it at every scrum if/when he can get away with it.


It’s amazing that he gets away with it in a case like the example cited, but even more shocking that refs don’t go into the games wise to his habit. The ref in the third test could have watched a few scrums from the second test and seen that boring into the hooker is the standard way that Porter tries to avoid the scrum contest.


It’s also not a minor thing. Scrum penalties can and do lead to games being won and lost.

P
PM 7 days ago

How Porter was favoured over Genge I will never understand. Porter was found wanting on this tour in every department and was no match for Tupou.

H
Hammer Head 7 days ago

I’m no scrum expert - but I would think that scrumming at an angle like that must be dangerous for the opposing hooker?


If so, why would it not be cited much like a dangerous clear out or high hit?


Or should we wait until someone’s neck gets broken?

D
DP 7 days ago

Damage done. He won’t get away with this again so I think it’s game over for Porter. Opposition coaches will be in every referees ear before a test match against Ireland.

A
Alex 7 days ago

Lol yep. That's it. Game over. Career done. Just retire already. Lol steady on

M
MC 7 days ago

It’s happened plenty before … even when he scrummed straight v NZ he got pinged by Barnes which cost Ireland dearly ..

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

TRENDING
TRENDING
Injury update: Joe Schmidt reveals toll of Lions tour on Wallabies big guns