Northern Edition
Select Edition
Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Why Steve Borthwick is the real winner from the Lions' latest victory

Head coach Steve Borthwick of England looks on before the match against the United States at Audi Field on July 19, 2025 in Washington, DC. (Photo by Scott Taetsch - RFU/The RFU Collection via Getty Images)

England currently have three fly-halves on the British & Irish Lions tour – Fin Smith, Marcus Smith and Owen Farrell – and, much to the consternation of some fans, probably their form fly-half George Ford fresh from three virtuoso performances in a white jersey against Argentina and the USA over the past month.

ADVERTISEMENT

What that means for Steve Borthwick is that he will have four players to choose from heading into the autumn, assuming the Saracens-bound Farrell makes himself eligible for England selection again.

Shifting Marcus Smith to full-back (George Furbank, Freddie Steward and Joe Carpenter may have something to say about that) may alleviate this issue slightly, but three into one is still not a great equation for Ford, Fin Smith and Marcus Smith.

But Andy Farrell may have done Borthwick a favour during the Lions’ narrow victory over the First Nations & Pasifika XV on Tuesday in Melbourne.

Match Summary

0
Penalty Goals
0
3
Tries
4
2
Conversions
2
0
Drop Goals
0
90
Carries
118
6
Line Breaks
12
10
Turnovers Lost
19
4
Turnovers Won
3

In what was otherwise a sketchy showing from the visitors, the English 10-12 axis of Fin Smith and Owen Farrell showed a lot of promise. There was, of course, the chip from Farrell for Jamie Osborne’s first try, the long whipped pass from Fin Smith for the Irishman’s second, or Farrell’s dummy and pass for Duhan van der Merwe’s try, but they were not stand-alone moments.

The pair fluidly shared the responsibilities at first-receiver, with the other often floating behind the first line of attack for a pull-back. Farrell said after the match that he “enjoyed” his partnership with the 23-year-old, describing him as a “fantastic player”.

Farrell, 10 years Fin Smith’s senior, has played a lot at inside centre with Ford at No.10, particularly during Eddie Jones’ tenure, where Borthwick was an assistant. While he has reverted back to fly-half in recent years, the No.12 shirt may be calling again given the performances from the playmakers this year.

ADVERTISEMENT

Inside centre has long been a problem for England, but there have been signs of promise this year with Fraser Dingwall during the Six Nations, as well as Seb Atkinson and Max Ojomoh showing in debuts against Argentina and the USA that they are more than deserving of another chance in the role.

Farrell’s return therefore muddies the waters for fly-halves and centres, but Borthwick would be a brave man to overlook him for the Autumn Nations Series. Likewise, Ford, Marcus Smith and Fin Smith are secure in the England squad too.

Shifting to inside centre may be the most viable option for Farrell currently, and on the evidence of what happened for the Lions, that won’t be too problematic.

Ever since Farrell confirmed his move back to the Gallagher Premiership, Borthwick must have been puzzling over what to do with all his fly-halves – Andy Farrell may have helped him out.

ADVERTISEMENT

Related


Enter our competition and you could be the lucky winner of a signed British and Irish Lions 2025 shirt! Enter here now

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

2 Comments
N
Neil 18 days ago

Firstly, OF has been a great player for England over many years, probably at his peak in 2016-2019 but there is I believe a false a narrative about OF being a great leader and driver of standards as a captain to the point that the press are now once again building him up in this regard without any real evidence.

From the point at which he took over the captaincy in 2019 to his sabbatical England’s win rate was only 50%. Truly great leaders have the ability to impact results and drag their teams over the line, I never felt this was the case.

I believe it was the wrong decision to make him captain, it helped neither him or the team in that period, as the first choice 10 he should have been allowed to get on and play without having the extras of captaincy which rather than the current narrative actually appeared to diminish his effect on the team and their performance.

Borthwick looks to be building a decent group of young players, I really don't see where OF now fits in without disrupting things. The press should leave him alone to play for Sarries

I can't help feel that the campaign to get him back into the England team is simply to provide them with a target for criticism later….. tall poppy syndrome…!

B
Bob Salad II 19 days ago

I agree with the Ford, F Smith, M. Smith FH pecking order. I offer no personal opinion on Farrell’s return to the England set-up other than to say it could potentially be disruptive to Borthwick’s long-term development of other upcoming players as regardless of whether he’s slotted back in at 10 or 12, his inclusion will impact playing opportunities for others. Do we really believe Farrell will be England’s starting 10/12 at the next WC when he’ll be 36? I think a bench berth is most likely over the next couple of England campaigns where he can still be involved free of captaincy and can impart his experience and leadership qualities onto the next generation.

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

TRENDING
TRENDING
Fissler Confidential: Feyi-Waboso latest target of rebel comp